eBay has been a household name in online commerce since its launch in 1995. What started as a simple auction-style site for collectibles has evolved into a massive global marketplace for everything from used electronics to brand-new fashion. For individuals looking to sell items in the U.S., eBay offers a versatile and well-established platform that continues to attract millions of active buyers and sellers. But like any marketplace, success on eBay depends on understanding how it works—its strengths, limitations, buyer behavior, and how to craft effective product listings.
In this post, we’ll dive deep into the pros and cons of selling on eBay, the types of products buyers typically go for, and how to create compelling listings that actually convert.
✅ The Pros of Selling on eBay
1. Huge Audience Reach
eBay has over 130 million active buyers worldwide. This means your products can be seen by a massive, built-in audience without needing to drive your own traffic like on a personal website.
2. Variety of Product Categories
You can sell almost anything on eBay: used clothing, collectibles, electronics, car parts, kitchenware, tools, musical instruments, and even vintage toys. It’s especially popular for secondhand goods.
3. Auction or Buy-It-Now Options
eBay allows for flexibility in how you sell:
- Auction-style listings can generate bidding wars for high-demand or rare items.
- Buy-It-Now pricing is great for straightforward, no-hassle sales.
4. Seller Protections and Feedback System
eBay offers a structured dispute resolution process and seller protection programs. The reputation-based feedback system also encourages positive buyer-seller interactions.
5. Tools and Analytics
eBay provides sellers with tools like sales reports, promotions manager, bulk listing editors, and traffic insights to improve performance and conversions.
For more information:
- Click here for more information on other platforms: Wakewall Seller’s Guide for Online Marketplaces
- eBay Niches Nobody Is Talking About (But Buyers Love)
- For more information about different states and local SEO click here: Wakewall’s 50-State SEO Guide for Small Businesses
- Offical link: ebay
To view other platforms, expand below:
| Platform | Category | Type | Fee Model |
|---|---|---|---|
| ebay | General Goods | Auction & Fixed Price | Fees apply |
| Facebook Marketplace | General Goods | Local & National | Free |
| Craigslist | General Goods | Local Classifieds | Free |
| OfferUp | General Goods | Local | Free / Optional Fees |
| Mercari | General Goods | Shipping or Local | Fees apply |
| Bonanza | General Goods | Fixed Price | Fees apply |
| Etsy | Handmade & Artisan | Online Marketplace | Fees apply |
| Lucasgift | Handmade & Artisan | Online Marketplace | Fees apply |
| Redbubble | Print-on-Demand | Custom Products | Commission-based |
| Spring (TeeSpring) | Print-on-Demand | Custom Products | Free / Commission |
| Society6 | Print-on-Demand | Custom Products | Commission-based |
| Gumroad | Digital Goods | Downloads & Subscriptions | Fees apply |
| Sellfy | Digital Goods | Digital & Physical | Subscription |
| Ko-fi | Digital Goods | Donations & Sales | Free / Optional Fees |
| Buy Me a Coffee | Digital Goods | Donations & Sales | Free / Optional Fees |
| Payhip | Digital Goods | Downloads & Memberships | Fees apply |
| Poshmark | Fashion | Mobile Fashion Marketplace | Fees apply |
| Depop | Fashion | Vintage & Trendy | Fees apply |
| Vinted | Fashion | Clothing Resale | No Seller Fees |
| Curtsy | Fashion | Women’s Fashion | Fees apply |
| 5miles | Fashion & General | Local Marketplace | Free / Optional Fees |
| BookScouter | Books | Price Comparison | Free |
| Amazon | Books & Goods | Individual Seller | Fees apply |
| eBid | General Goods | Auction | Low Fees |
| Autotrader | Vehicles | For Sale Listings | Listing Fee |
| Cars.com | Vehicles | For Sale Listings | Listing Fee |
| PartingOut | Auto Parts | Marketplace | Free / Optional Fees |
| Chairish | Furniture & Decor | Curated Marketplace | Commission-based |
| AptDeco | Furniture | Local Delivery | Fees apply |
| Reverb | Musical Gear | Specialty Platform | Fees apply |
| StockX | Sneakers & Apparel | Authentication Based | Fees apply |
| GOAT | Sneakers & Apparel | Authentication Based | Fees apply |
| TheRealReal | Designer Goods | Consignment | Commission-based |
| ThredUp | Clothing | Consignment | Commission-based |
❌ The Cons of Selling on eBay
1. Fees Can Add Up
eBay charges insertion fees (for more than 250 monthly listings), final value fees (usually 12.9% for most items), and PayPal or managed payment fees. This can eat into your margins—especially for lower-cost items.
2. Competitive Market
Due to its size, eBay is highly competitive. Many categories are saturated, and you may be competing with large-scale sellers or overseas suppliers with lower prices.
3. Returns and Buyer Claims
Buyers are favored in most disputes. Sellers may be required to accept returns even when the item was sold “as-is.” False claims can be frustrating and costly.
4. Shipping Responsibilities
You’re responsible for packaging and shipping items promptly. Buyers expect tracking information and timely delivery, which means staying on top of logistics.
5. Time Investment
If you’re managing listings, photography, customer messages, packing, and shipping by yourself, selling on eBay can become a time-consuming side hustle.
Click to download WAKEWALL today
🛒 What Buyers Tend to Buy on eBay
Understanding what sells best on eBay can help you identify profitable niches or declutter strategically.
Popular Categories Include:
- Used electronics (phones, cameras, gaming consoles)
- Vintage collectibles (toys, comics, coins, cards)
- Clothing & accessories (brand-name apparel, shoes, watches)
- Home improvement tools and automotive parts
- Books & media (especially rare or out-of-print editions)
- Small kitchen appliances (mixers, blenders)
- Luxury items (watches, handbags, sunglasses)
- Crafts & hobby supplies (sewing, painting, woodworking)
Buyer Behavior Trends:
- Bargain hunters looking for deals on used or refurbished goods
- Collectors searching for rare or niche items
- Last-minute buyers looking for fast-shipping options
- International buyers interested in U.S.-based products
Many buyers use eBay specifically for things they can’t find easily on Amazon or in stores—making it a great platform for hard-to-find, discontinued, or gently-used goods.
🧾 Listing Formats: Auction vs. Buy-It-Now
When creating a listing on eBay, you have two primary formats:
1. Auction
- You set a starting price and a duration (usually 1–10 days)
- Buyers place bids, and the highest bidder wins
- Best for rare, vintage, or highly collectible items
Pros:
- Can drive up the final price if multiple bidders compete
- Good for items with uncertain value
Cons:
- Risk of selling too low if bidding is minimal
- Requires more attention and timing strategy
2. Buy-It-Now (BIN)
- You set a fixed price
- Buyers can purchase instantly without waiting
Pros:
- Fast and easy for both parties
- Predictable profit margins
Cons:
- Less excitement or bidding wars
- Needs competitive pricing to stand out
Pro tip: eBay allows hybrid listings with both an auction and a BIN option, giving buyers flexibility.
📝 How to Write Winning Product Titles and Descriptions
Product Titles: eBay SEO Essentials
eBay’s search engine (Cassini) scans your title heavily to determine visibility in search results. A strong title increases the chances of being seen and clicked.
Tips for Writing eBay Titles:
- Use all 80 characters available
- Include brand, model, size, color, condition, and keywords
- Avoid fluff words like “WOW!” or “LOOK!”
- Use common search terms buyers would type (e.g., “iPhone 13 Pro Max 128GB Unlocked”)
- Don’t use all caps or symbols unnecessarily
Example Title (Good):
“Apple iPhone 13 Pro Max 128GB Sierra Blue (Unlocked) – Excellent Condition”
Example Title (Bad):
“COOL iPhone!!! MUST SEE! 💥”
Product Descriptions: Clarity + Confidence
A good description provides details and builds trust. It should answer buyer questions before they ask.
What to Include:
- Product condition: new, used, refurbished (with clear signs of use if applicable)
- Specs or features: sizes, measurements, model numbers, compatibility
- Defects or wear: honesty prevents disputes
- What’s included: accessories, manuals, packaging
- Shipping & returns: estimated delivery time, return policy
Tone and Formatting:
- Keep it concise and well-structured
- Use bullet points for readability
- Avoid long paragraphs or overly promotional language
- Consider adding keywords from your title again for SEO
Example Description:
This listing is for an Apple iPhone 13 Pro Max, 128GB, in Sierra Blue.
- Condition: Excellent, lightly used with no scratches
- Fully unlocked for use on all carriers
- Includes original box, charger, and USB-C cable
- iOS updated and ready to activate
- Ships within 24 hours via USPS Priority Mail
Returns accepted within 30 days. Buy with confidence!
🚀 How Wakewall Can Help Your Business Sell Better on eBay
If you’re a small business or independent seller using eBay to reach customers, Wakewall can become a powerful companion to amplify your visibility, organization, and customer engagement—especially when you’re juggling multiple platforms.
Here’s how Wakewall can support your eBay selling strategy:
1. Centralize Your Product Reminders & Launch Timelines
With Wakewall’s robust reminder system, you can schedule notifications for:
- eBay auction endings
- When to relist unsold items
- Inventory restock dates
- Seasonal promotions and eBay fee-free listing days
Never miss an opportunity to optimize timing on high-demand products or sales events.
2. Promote Your eBay Listings with Public Posts
Use your Wakewall business profile to post updates, photos, or promotions linking directly to your eBay store or product listings. It’s like a mini social feed where your followers and potential buyers can see what’s new—perfect for creating visibility outside of eBay’s algorithm.
3. Organize Listings and Inventory Notes
Keep product-specific notes for items you sell across platforms. You can:
- Track sold-out SKUs
- Jot down condition details or repair info for used items
- Upload photos and documentation
Your Wakewall notes can act like a behind-the-scenes inventory journal.
4. Build an Audience and Drive External Traffic
eBay is a powerful marketplace, but you don’t “own” your customer base. Wakewall allows you to grow a following tied to your brand, not just your eBay username. As your audience engages with your Wakewall profile, you can send them to new listings or even your own storefront later on.
5. Use Hashtags to Get Discovered
Tag your Wakewall posts with relevant product categories like #electronics, #vintage, #resellerlife, or #refurbished. Users browsing these tags might stumble upon your business—even if they weren’t initially looking for you on eBay.
6. Local Business Visibility
Selling bulky or fragile items locally? Wakewall’s location-aware discovery helps nearby users find your business. You can list your eBay items and also note that they’re available for local pickup or cash sales, helping you avoid fees while building relationships in your community.
eBay handles the transactions—Wakewall helps you build a brand around them.
Together, they can give your resale or product-based business both reach and personality. Whether you’re a niche seller, thrift flipper, or small-scale brand, integrating Wakewall into your eBay operation can give you a modern edge with better marketing, management, and long-term customer growth.
Final Thoughts
Selling on eBay is still a powerful way for individuals in the U.S. to generate income, clear out clutter, or build a side hustle. Its massive reach, wide product category support, and flexible pricing formats make it especially appealing for unique, secondhand, or collectible items. However, it’s not without challenges: fees, competition, and return policies can be drawbacks, especially for casual sellers.
The key to success lies in strategic listing practices—choosing the right products, pricing competitively, and writing high-quality titles and descriptions that are clear, honest, and keyword-optimized.
If you’re considering selling on eBay, start small, track your results, and scale from there. With time and practice, it can be a rewarding and profitable platform.
